Economist: State ignores its own studies about Delta
by Gene Beley, CVBT Delta Correspondent

October 13, 2013 9:00pm
Comment Print Email

•  Studies contract those pushing Delta tunnels

•  “I’ve come to the conclusion that being an advocate is a good thing”

(Note: Please see videos at the end of this text story to watch Mr. Michael and others)

In touting twin tunnels to siphon off part of the Sacramento River, the California Department of Water Resources is ignoring years of advice from its own experts, says University of the Pacific economist Michael Jeffrey.

He says this research bolsters his own, in three detailed cost analysis over four years, that show that shoring up the levees in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta is the most economical way to ensure water supplies for the San Joaquin Valley and Southern California. What doesn’t work, he says is the Bay Delta Conservation Plan’s call to build massive twin tunnels beneath the Delta.

If built, as advocated by Gov. Jerry Brown and his allies, the 35-mile-long tunnels, each wide enough to let a small plane fly through them, would have the potential capacity to drain enough water out of the Sacramento River and into the state and federal irrigation systems south of the Delta to fill the Rose Bowl to its brim every 30 minutes. However, proponents say the tunnels would not operate at maximum capacity.

The cost of the project has been estimated as high as $54 billion, when interest on the project’s debt is included.

But the university economist says his research shows a better, cheaper, way to go – something that’s been sitting in the storage rooms of the state government for years.

“I found a whole stack of reports in the Department of Water Resources that came to the same conclusion as mine — that the first rational step in this process is to invest in the levee system,” says Mr. Michael, who is director of the Business Forecasting Center and associate professor in the Eberhardt School of Business at the University of the Pacific.

He says this research is being covered up by the long-running campaign in favor of the tunnels.

“It was clear to me that there was a lot of misinformation going on there. And there hadn’t been any real attempt at economic costs analysis, which is what governments do when they are pondering billion dollar infrastructure investments,” Mr. Michael told a meeting last week of the Delta advocacy group Restore the Delta.

The flood of misinformation was not accidental, his remarks suggest.

“We had Congressional representatives in 2009 running around the Valley blaming everything on a two-inch fish called the Delta smelt. This upset me as an economist because we were in the third year of a severe drought, but less than 5 percent of irrigated agriculture in the state had been fallow,” he said.

“But the owners of that 5 percent have polluted the media, flying in reporters from New York, who drove right past the real economic problems in the Valley and took a photo of one of those fallowed fields and blamed everything on the two-inch fish,” he said.

His first published report on water and the Valley economy was titled “Unemployment in the San Joaquin Valley — Fish or Foreclosures?” Mr. Michael says the title was inspired by a program produced by Sean Hannity, a commentator for the Fox cable network, which blamed the endangered fish for the farmers’ woes.

Mr. Michael says the true cause of unemployment in the Valley was the mortgage meltdown and collapse of the housing industry – not lack of water for irrigated crops.

He said that after four years and doing three significant economics studies on the subject, he’s reached the conclusion that the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) with its twin tunnels scheme at its heart is bad for the state. “There are less costly and better solutions,” he said.

“The BDCP brought in a panel of national experts to review this crazy thing that we had researched. What was interesting to me was that they said our levee recommendations were too weak for the safety needs of the Delta. We said the state needs to do more. Their expert said the earthquake risk to the water exporters did not justify a multi-billion investment in a tunnel or canal.”

“Cost analysis were coming from everywhere -- state legislature, academics, editorial pages of newspapers,” Mr. Michael continued.

“By the summer of 2012 I drafted my own benefit cost report showing $2.50 in cost for every $1 of benefit to the state. Very bad investment,” he noted. “The farmers simply can’t afford the tunnels.”

Under the BDCP plan, those getting water from the tunnels, from San Joaquin Valley farmers to customers of the Metropolitan Water District, which serves much of Southern Califirna, would pay to build them. Taxpayers would pick up the multi-billion dollar tab to restore the Delta’s ecology.

But those buying the water don’t have to use a drop of it themselves – they’d be free to resell it to whoever wrote them the biggest checks. Vast amount of fresh water, such as that to be shipped through the tunnels, is needed for fracking – the method of fracturing underground rock formations to free up oil and natural gas.

The oil industry is eyeing the Central Valley’s Monterey shale formation, a vast 1,750 square mile, 1,900-foot-thick, rock formation about 9,000-11,000 feet beneath the Valley, stretching from Modesto south to Bakersfield. If estimates are correct it could contain one of the world's largest land-based reserves of shale oil, estimated by the federal government to be as much as 15.4 billion barrels of oil.

Argonne National Laboratory's Robert Horner, a policy analyst, energy/environmental systems specialist in its Washington, D.C., office, says fracking of a shale formation for oil or natural gas can take between 2.5 million and 5.5 million gallons of clean water. Andrew Bunger, assistant professor in the Department of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering and the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at the University of Pittsburgh, offers a more specific number: “Approximately 4 million gallons for one typical horizontal well (similar to growing 40 acres of irrigated crops for one year),” he told CVBT in July.

Both experts say that the current state of the art in fracking requires fresh, clean water that is then mixed with proprietary formulas of grit and chemicals.

Mr. Michael was the keynote speaker at the Restore the Delta fundraiser, at which he received an award from the group.

“I’ve come to the conclusion that being an advocate is a good thing,” he said. “A Delta advocate cares about this special place. They want future generations to enjoy a Delta that is fishable, farmable, swimable and all those nice things. But being a Delta advocate is being more than that. To me, it means facts over fear, being an advocate for good government and demanding that government agencies follow their own rules and be responsible for taxpayer dollars. It means standing up for enduring value, and having an environmental sustainability, fairness, democracy, and the rule of law.”

Restore the Delta’s rally and fundraiser in the South Delta’s River Mill winery Oct. 10 resulted in donations of more than $500,000. Barbara Barrigan-Perrilla, the group’s executive director, said there would be an announcement soon, after the accounting is completed, that may push the figure even higher.

U.O.P.'s Dr. Jeffrey Michael Delivers Keynote Address at Restore the Delta Rally from Gene Beley on Vimeo.

Comedian-Actor Jack Gallagher Headlines at Restore the Delta's Rally That Raised More than $500,000! from Gene Beley on Vimeo.

Restore the Delta's Barbara Barrigan-Parilla Advertises Job for Any Neighbors of Governor Jerry Brown from Gene Beley on Vimeo.

Restore the Delta Advocate & Special Recognition Awards Presented at Rally from Gene Beley on Vimeo.

Comment Print Email

Comments on this story

Rosie 10/14/13 1:35 PM
if you shore up the levees you still don't address the issue of flow direction, the current situation reverses the natural flow direction of the delta, the tunnels would return the flow to more natural conditions (fish would be happier).

  • How to compete against Wal-Mart
  • Stockton mom turns a need into a business
  • The entrepreneur is in
  • Writing her own success story
  • Growing a small business the family way
  • The future pencils positive for this company
  • Niche marketing -- Italian style
  • Sipping success with niche marketing
  • Roasting a business out of his passion
  • Success as an independent consultant takes more than expertise
  • Avoiding the traps of employee law violations
  • Cracking the voice-over market
  • The American Dream realized, one package at a time
  • Female winemaker plunges into business
  • A new take on nurse education
  • Family sees moving business success
  • STEM thrives in pockets of education innovation
  • STEM goes solar in Stockton
  • Quick! There’s a robot in my pool
  • Retiring seniors can mean new business
  • Predawn biotech class trains next generation of science workers
  • Staying ahead of the competition the old fashioned way
  • Central Valley sees mismatch between high-tech jobs and job seekers
  • STEM starts young
  • Get ready – the future is here now
  • STEM Education: Growing the Valley's Future
  • They’re low power in wattage only, not ideas
  • Thinking success spawns Successful Thinkers
  • Small business success can mean finding the right niche
  • This franchise has real muscle behind it
  • Getting the scoop on small business success
  • Reshoring could rebuild America's manufacturing
  • Marketing that’s deliberately anchored to the past
  • Guitar artist plays his way to success
  • Paralysis no handicap for this entrepreneur
  • Boost sales with better communication
  • Making sandwiches sexy with a franchise
  • Going solar without spending a lot of money
  • They’re cute and cuddly. But are they a business?
  • Opportunity sails forth in the Delta
  • How bad etiquette on the job could kill your career
  • Growing their way out of hunger and poverty
  • Finding small business success from floor to ceiling
  • Why he’s public enemy #1 – for gophers
  • Running a home-based business successfully
  • Your boss needs a vacation – really
  • Couple makes transition from big corporations to small business
  • Carving a small business niche with a better idea
  • Calm is the goal of computer service and education franchisor
  • Developer squeezing new life into downtown with juice franchise
  • Signs of a recovering economy
  • How to keep a family business in the family
  • Ford dealership expands despite the Great Recession
  • Utility Telephone connects with customer service
  • Crowdfunding basics
  • The roar from crowdfunding is getting louder
  • California water wars’ bulldog
  • Water wars heat up in California
  • Helping businesses grow with a stronger STEM
  • How to retain your best employees
  • Small business runs success up the pole
  • Winery expands in Lodi
  • Lodi wineries tapping into growing Chinese market
  • Has the jobs picture brightened for the Valley for 2012?
  • The right education will be needed for 21st Century jobs
  • Where new jobs for San Joaquin will come from
  • Developing jobs for San Joaquin – Part 2
  • Developing jobs for San Joaquin
  • Fruits of his labor
  • Helping grow food security in the Valley of plenty
  • Doing a business turnaround despite the recession
  • Keeping customers loyal helps build her business
  • Expo exposes businesses to utility contracting ideas
  • Drink mix maker taps expertise to blend success
  • Entrepreneur finds success in a basket
  • Tips for catching resume fraud
  • There’s no checking out for this small business owner
  • Entrepreneurs take Valley sports play-by-play to the world
  • Starting a winery from scratch
  • Job hunting tips for the long-term unemployed
  • In the Central Valley, opera isn’t always the Grand Ole Opry
  • Branding ideas for small businesses
  • The ump’s not blind, but the players are
  • Finding success by tapping your brain in a new way - Part Two
  • Finding success by tapping your brain in a new way
  • Machines talking to machines is the future
  • Getting involved in the fight against AIDS
  • Franchised divorce says it’s a better way
  • Small business owner is brewing a success story
  • To beat the Great Recession, they’ve expanded
  • Taking a swing at strokes
  • Alert your taste buds – here comes Taste of San Joaquin
  • This franchise has real muscle behind it
  • Passion for his city drives him
  • Vicente Fox speaks out on U.S.-Mexico relations
  • Give your support staff recognition and reap top performance
  • Central Valley baker gets top honors for Royal Wedding pie
  • Asparagus Festival ends on high note
  • Stockton close to annual ‘tipping’ point
  • Framing small business success
  • Small business sees Affordable Care Act helping its bottom line
  • What you eat – and when – helps local restaurants
  • Coping with the aftermath of foreclosure
  • How to raise charming children
  • Central Valley grad school goes all-iPads
  • Solution to Delta water wars voiced
  • Making sure your personal bottom line is covered
  • Small California winemaker is all family
  • Small winery relies on family and innovation to compete
  • Central Valley company says it has a better way to store solar power
  • What’s wrong -- and right -- about local TV news
  • What planning means to small business success
  • Making the leap to small business
  • Out of work at middle age? Experts offer advice
  • Small business marketing, one article at a time
  • Congress on your corner as it’s supposed to be
  • Central Valley city’s heritage rediscovered
  • Central Valley school is building students’ foundations
  • Job tips from the expert
  • Long-term jobless worker re-invents himself
  • Building a new power plant means jobs for Central Valley
  • Sacramento reaches for the stars with new science center
  • Lodi Chamber opens China’s doors to small business
  • Writing books for fun – and sometimes profit
  • Black Friday shopping? How to protect yourself from scams
  • California winemakers can find added rewards overseas
  • Wine makers tap overseas markets from Lodi
  • A new revenue stream for Central Valley small businesses
  • Food bank seeks more business support
  • Tips for finding a job in the Great Recession
  • State may solve some of its prison woes with new Stockton facility
  • A solution to underwater mortgages
  • Should public libraries be managed by private firms?
  • Central Valley moves ahead with critical water project
  • Dee Dee Myers and the increasing impact of women on small business
  • How women are growing their small businesses
  • A market with a mission
  • Retailer 'paints' solutions to cash flow challenge
  • An answer for the unemployed – return to school
  • A ‘golden’ small business success story
  • Central Valley winegrapes blessed
  • Rubbing out the recession with a franchise
  • Surviving the recession as a small business
  • It’s personal, union says of Stockton fire cuts
  • How old it too old to start a new business?
  • They've found the recipe for small business success
  • MBA students help revive Central Valley farmers market
  • Classic wooden yachts anchor in Stockton for weekend
  • Foreclosures, short sales – a bank president comments
  • The strength of family helps this small business compete
  • Festival spears success in Central Valley
  • Social media helps keep family business prospering
  • Central Valley students get training in ‘green’ futures
  • Knives readied as Valley cities slash services
  • Central Valley jobless picture still grim
  • Delta residents told to ready for water war
  • Opportunities outlined for Central Valley small businesses
  • Rewiring your brain for success
  • Central Valley no longer ‘shell shocked’ by recession
  • To fix California’s government, look to London
  • Taking your sales pitch to the next level